OPEX Benchmark

OPEX cost-efficiency analysis

100 units · 17 November 2026
Demonstration data (synthetic)Evaluation mode

01Key findings

Savings potential
206.2m PLN
5.5% of the cost of the units in the analysis
at least 47.1m PLN with 95% probability
at the 90% target; units below it: 46
Excess cost
470.0m PLN
12.6% of the cost of the units in the analysis
Average cost efficiency
89%
cost-weighted 87% · target 90%
Units below target
46 of 98
5 with high priority
Records to verify
2
A017, A028

What the data say

  • The data show inefficiency: costs above the efficient level form a clear right tail (skewness statistic z = 2.68, threshold 1.645).
  • The average unit works at 89% cost efficiency; cost above the efficient level totals 470.0m PLN (12.6% of cost).
  • Expected saving at the 90% target: 206.2m PLN (5.5% of cost), each unit weighted by the probability that it is below the target; with 95% probability it is at least 47.1m PLN.
  • Secure: A009, A083, A014, A073, A093 (59.9m PLN); large but uncertain: A081, A058, A074, A085, A070 (+2) (58.7m PLN); conditional on quality: A075, A016, A050, A055, A047 (+4) (45.9m PLN).
  • The result holds under other assumptions: savings between 3.9% and 5.7% of cost.
  • Higher inefficiency goes most strongly with failure or fault rate and asset age (cross-validated R² 0.37). These are associations, not proof of cause.
  • Costs far from what the scale implies: A017, A028. These records need a check before any conclusion. If the records of A017, A028 are real, the expected saving rises to 318.5m PLN.
  • On total cost (OPEX + CAPEX) the ranking largely holds (rank correlation 0.86); units to check for capitalisation or renewal plans: 6.

02Savings portfolio

The saving is a programme, not a list of actions. Each unit's saving is weighted by the probability that the unit is below the target, and the units fall into baskets by how certain and how large their saving is. The defensible amount is the lower tail: the saving reached with 95% probability.

Expected saving
206.2m PLN
weighted by the probability that each unit is below the target
Defensible saving
47.1m PLN
reached with 95% probability
Secure basket
59.9m PLN
units: 5 · at least 12.5m PLN with 95% probability
If the records to verify are real
318.5m PLN
A017, A028: 112.3m PLN more
Expected saving by basket050m100mSecure5 units59.9m PLNLarge but uncertain7 units58.7m PLNConditional on quality9 units45.9m PLNOther77 units41.7m PLNTo verify (data)2 units · outside the totals112.3m PLNBars: expected saving; whiskers: from the 5% to the 95% quantile.
BasketExpected savingAt least (95% probability)ShareWhat to do
Secure
A009, A083, A014, A073, A093
59.9m PLN12.5m PLN29%Probability of being below the target at least 90%: plan the saving and assign owners.
Large but uncertain
A081, A058, A074, A085, A070, A089 (+1)
58.7m PLN6.4m PLN28%Large expected saving, but the unit may already meet the target: confirm it with a cost review before committing.
Conditional on quality
A075, A016, A050, A055, A047, A052 (+3)
45.9m PLN8.3m PLN22%Quality among the worst 20% of the units on SAIDI or SAIFI: the saving is not counted until a plan shows that the cuts keep quality within the requirements.
Other
77 units
41.7m PLN10.2m PLN20%Small or improbable savings spread over many units: monitor them, without a programme for single units.
To verify (data)
A028, A017
112.3m PLN61.6m PLNRecords set aside by the screening rule: outside the totals, see the scenario below.

Quality condition

A saving is not counted where quality is among the worst 20% of the units on SAIDI or SAIFI. Held back: A075, A016, A050, A055, A047, A052 (+3) (expected 45.9m PLN); cuts there need a plan that keeps quality within the regulator's requirements. Counted saving (without the basket conditional on quality): 160.3m PLN, at least 36.0m PLN with 95% probability.

UnitBasketExpected savingSAIDI (threshold 130)SAIFI (threshold 2.38)
A009Secure22.3m PLN99.82.03
A081Large but uncertain19.9m PLN54.90.954
A058Large but uncertain19.7m PLN37.70.721
A083Secure15.7m PLN76.21.29
A014Secure13.4m PLN1121.89
A075Conditional on quality8.1m PLN⚠ 318⚠ 3.63
A016Conditional on quality7.3m PLN⚠ 131⚠ 2.46
A074Large but uncertain6.2m PLN44.01.09
A050Conditional on quality6.0m PLN104⚠ 2.53
A055Conditional on quality5.4m PLN89.4⚠ 2.46

Controllable part: 199.4m PLN of the expected 206.2m PLN lies in components the units control (own labour, contracted services, fault repair, vegetation management). Components outside their control (shared services, taxes and fees) carry 26.2m PLN of excess in the units below the target; that part needs a decision above unit level (allocation keys, local fees).

Scenario: records to verify

A017, A028: cost far above what the frontier variables imply (robust z: A017 6.3; A028 8.9). The base totals leave them out. If the records are real, the expected saving grows by 112.3m PLN (at least 61.6m PLN with 95% probability) to 318.5m PLN in total.

Check before any conclusion
  • Allocation keys: are central costs allocated to the unit on the same keys as to the others?
  • Shared costs: does the cost include services shared with other units or the head office?
  • One-off events: storms, major failures, settlements or provisions in the year?
  • Capitalisation policy: are the same expenditures capitalised as in the other units?
  • Scope: do the frontier variables describe everything the cost covers (the whole network, area or activity)?
VariantExpected savingAt least (95% probability)
Base (records to verify left out)206.2m PLN47.1m PLN
If the records are real318.5m PLN109.9m PLN

03Do the data show inefficiency?

Costs above the efficient level should show up as a long right tail of the cost residuals. Here they do, so the report gives efficiencies and savings.

Do the data show inefficiency?inefficiency establishedthreshold 1.645 (5% level)-2-1012345z = 2.68
  • Screening: 2 set aside (robust z of the cost residual above 3.5 in absolute value)
  • Curvature: no size term needed (coefficient 0.011, 95% interval -0.010 to 0.031)
  • Frontier variables: customers, network length (km), stations, energy delivered, service area (km²), forest cover, cable share

04Cost efficiency of the units

Each point is the estimated cost efficiency of a unit: 100% means cost at the efficient frontier for its scale and conditions. The vertical line is the 95% interval. Units in blue are below the 90% target.

Cost efficiency of the units50%60%70%80%90%100%target 90%below target (46)at or above target (52)A009A030← lowest efficiencyhighest efficiency →
Data table
UnitGroupEfficiency95% intervalRank
A009Urban66.7%[55.6%; 92.6%]77 to 98
A075Sparse67.3%[55.2%; 93.5%]71 to 98
A083Urban74.4%[62.6%; 95.9%]53 to 98
A050Rural74.4%[63.0%; 95.5%]53 to 98
A062Rural76.1%[64.6%; 95.9%]47 to 97
A016Rural77.3%[65.5%; 96.6%]39 to 97
A014Urban77.5%[64.9%; 96.6%]38 to 97
A093Rural78.2%[66.1%; 96.8%]35 to 97
A073Suburban79.1%[67.6%; 97.0%]34 to 96
A052Rural79.3%[67.2%; 97.2%]32 to 96
A002Sparse80.5%[68.2%; 97.5%]28 to 96
A058Urban80.6%[68.5%; 97.5%]27 to 96
A081Urban80.9%[68.8%; 97.7%]26 to 96
A066Rural81.3%[69.8%; 97.7%]27 to 95
A070Suburban82.7%[71.5%; 97.9%]23 to 94
A022Suburban83.0%[71.6%; 97.8%]21 to 95
A047Sparse83.1%[70.5%; 98.5%]16 to 95
A089Suburban83.5%[72.5%; 98.1%]20 to 94
A068Rural83.6%[72.2%; 98.3%]18 to 94
A088Sparse83.9%[72.5%; 98.4%]17 to 93
A001Sparse84.1%[72.0%; 98.3%]16 to 94
A003Sparse84.3%[72.7%; 98.4%]18 to 94
A091Rural85.2%[73.1%; 98.6%]13 to 93
A100Suburban85.3%[73.8%; 98.4%]16 to 92
A040Sparse85.5%[74.1%; 98.4%]15 to 92
A032Sparse85.7%[73.4%; 98.6%]13 to 93
A039Sparse86.4%[74.8%; 98.7%]11 to 92
A021Urban86.5%[74.7%; 98.8%]10 to 91
A074Urban86.5%[74.5%; 98.8%]11 to 92
A085Urban87.3%[74.3%; 99.1%]8 to 92
A051Sparse87.3%[76.1%; 98.8%]10 to 90
A026Suburban87.4%[76.0%; 98.9%]10 to 90
A094Urban87.5%[75.3%; 99.0%]9 to 91
A092Rural87.6%[75.4%; 99.0%]8 to 91
A087Suburban87.6%[76.5%; 99.0%]9 to 90
A064Suburban87.7%[76.3%; 99.0%]8 to 89
A055Urban88.7%[76.8%; 99.2%]7 to 88
A005Sparse89.1%[75.3%; 99.4%]5 to 91
A012Suburban89.4%[78.1%; 99.2%]6 to 87
A038Sparse89.5%[78.5%; 99.4%]5 to 86
A029Sparse89.6%[77.5%; 99.3%]6 to 87
A063Urban89.6%[78.7%; 99.3%]6 to 86
A071Urban89.7%[78.5%; 99.3%]5 to 87
A031Rural89.8%[79.2%; 99.2%]6 to 86
A095Rural89.8%[78.8%; 99.4%]5 to 87
A079Rural89.8%[79.1%; 99.3%]6 to 86
A082Suburban90.3%[78.7%; 99.4%]5 to 87
A023Sparse90.3%[78.0%; 99.5%]4 to 88
A076Suburban90.4%[79.3%; 99.5%]4 to 86
A018Urban90.4%[79.3%; 99.3%]5 to 86
A037Urban90.5%[79.3%; 99.4%]4 to 86
A006Suburban90.6%[79.2%; 99.5%]5 to 85
A060Suburban90.6%[79.5%; 99.4%]5 to 85
A080Sparse90.6%[79.3%; 99.5%]4 to 85
A015Suburban90.7%[79.6%; 99.4%]5 to 85
A034Suburban91.1%[79.5%; 99.5%]3 to 85
A084Sparse91.5%[80.5%; 99.6%]3 to 82
A035Sparse91.7%[80.7%; 99.6%]3 to 83
A025Suburban91.7%[81.3%; 99.5%]4 to 82
A061Suburban91.7%[80.9%; 99.6%]3 to 83
A086Suburban91.8%[81.3%; 99.5%]3 to 82
A010Urban91.9%[81.2%; 99.6%]3 to 83
A013Suburban91.9%[81.1%; 99.6%]3 to 83
A048Suburban92.0%[79.2%; 99.7%]2 to 85
A054Rural92.1%[81.3%; 99.6%]3 to 82
A065Urban92.6%[82.1%; 99.6%]3 to 81
A045Rural92.7%[82.4%; 99.7%]2 to 80
A057Suburban92.8%[82.5%; 99.7%]3 to 79
A046Sparse92.9%[82.2%; 99.7%]2 to 79
A033Rural93.2%[83.2%; 99.7%]2 to 78
A020Rural93.4%[83.4%; 99.7%]2 to 79
A027Rural93.4%[83.7%; 99.7%]2 to 77
A067Urban93.4%[83.3%; 99.7%]2 to 78
A053Rural93.4%[83.2%; 99.7%]2 to 80
A036Urban93.4%[83.2%; 99.7%]2 to 78
A043Sparse93.6%[83.6%; 99.8%]2 to 77
A097Urban93.7%[83.4%; 99.7%]2 to 78
A041Urban93.8%[83.9%; 99.8%]2 to 78
A078Suburban93.9%[84.2%; 99.7%]2 to 76
A099Rural94.0%[84.4%; 99.7%]2 to 75
A098Rural94.1%[84.2%; 99.8%]2 to 76
A056Urban94.1%[84.3%; 99.8%]2 to 77
A077Urban94.2%[84.7%; 99.7%]2 to 75
A096Urban94.4%[84.8%; 99.8%]2 to 75
A011Rural94.4%[84.5%; 99.8%]2 to 75
A090Rural94.5%[85.1%; 99.8%]2 to 73
A004Sparse94.6%[85.5%; 99.8%]2 to 73
A008Urban94.8%[85.3%; 99.8%]2 to 74
A024Rural94.8%[85.5%; 99.8%]2 to 73
A042Sparse95.2%[86.2%; 99.8%]2 to 71
A007Sparse95.3%[86.2%; 99.8%]1 to 72
A072Sparse95.3%[86.6%; 99.8%]1 to 71
A049Suburban95.4%[86.2%; 99.8%]1 to 70
A059Suburban95.7%[87.1%; 99.9%]1 to 69
A019Rural95.8%[87.2%; 99.9%]1 to 70
A044Sparse96.7%[89.4%; 99.9%]1 to 63
A069Suburban97.1%[90.3%; 99.9%]1 to 58
A030Urban97.4%[90.9%; 99.9%]1 to 57

05Where the money goes

Observed cost splits into the efficient cost for each unit's scale and conditions and the excess above it. The part of the excess recoverable at the 90% target is the saving.

Where the money goesCost of the units in the analysis: 3.74bn PLNEfficient cost3.27bn PLN · 87.4%Saving at the 90% target206.2m PLN · 5.5%Other excess cost263.8m PLN · 7.1%

Saving at the target by unit (largest 15)

Saving at the target by unit (largest 15)020m40mA009Area 922.3m PLNA081Area 8119.9m PLNA058Area 5819.7m PLNA083Area 8315.7m PLNA014Area 1413.4m PLNA075Area 758.1m PLNA016Area 167.3m PLNA074Area 746.2m PLNA050Area 506.0m PLNA055Area 555.4m PLNA047Area 475.3m PLNA073Area 735.0m PLNA052Area 524.5m PLNA085Area 854.2m PLNA070Area 703.7m PLNBars: expected saving; whiskers: 95% interval.
Data table
UnitNameSaving at target95%
A009Area 922.3m PLN[0 PLN; 32.7m PLN]
A081Area 8119.9m PLN[0 PLN; 44.0m PLN]
A058Area 5819.7m PLN[0 PLN; 42.8m PLN]
A083Area 8315.7m PLN[0 PLN; 27.1m PLN]
A014Area 1413.4m PLN[0 PLN; 26.2m PLN]
A075Area 758.1m PLN[0 PLN; 12.4m PLN]
A016Area 167.3m PLN[0 PLN; 13.6m PLN]
A074Area 746.2m PLN[0 PLN; 20.3m PLN]
A050Area 506.0m PLN[0 PLN; 10.3m PLN]
A055Area 555.4m PLN[0 PLN; 22.5m PLN]
A047Area 475.3m PLN[0 PLN; 13.3m PLN]
A073Area 735.0m PLN[0 PLN; 9.9m PLN]
A052Area 524.5m PLN[0 PLN; 9.2m PLN]
A085Area 854.2m PLN[0 PLN; 15.4m PLN]
A070Area 703.7m PLN[0 PLN; 8.6m PLN]

06How robust the result is

The same portfolio saving under other reasonable assumptions about the inefficiency. A narrow spread means the conclusions do not hinge on these modelling choices.

How robust the result is0%2.5%5%7.5%Assumptions of this report5.5%Prior median efficiency 0.705.7%Prior median efficiency 0.954.9%Exponential law3.9%
Axis: saving at the target, % of cost; line: 95% interval.
Data table
Assumption%95%
Assumptions of this report5.5%[0.2%; 8.9%]
Prior median efficiency 0.705.7%[0.6%; 9.2%]
Prior median efficiency 0.954.9%[0.0%; 8.8%]
Exponential law3.9%[0.6%; 6.7%]

07Investment and total cost (TOTEX)

A unit can look efficient on OPEX by capitalising costs or by deferring renewals. The same frontier fitted to total cost (OPEX + CAPEX) shows whether the ranking holds; units far from the diagonal moved by a quarter of the ranking or more.

Investment and total cost (TOTEX)capitalisation?deferred renewal?offset by low CAPEXother units2020404060608080Rank on OPEX (1 = best)Rank on TOTEX (1 = best)A059A096A067A020A033A063
Solid line: same rank on both views; dashed lines: a move of 25 places or more.
  • The two rankings largely agree (rank correlation 0.86).
  • On total cost the data also show inefficiency (skewness z = 2.42); expected TOTEX saving at the target 227.4m PLN (3.4% of total cost).
  • Capital cost is 44% of the total cost of the units in the analysis.
UnitSignalRank OPEXRank TOTEXCapital cost shareAsset ageWhat to check
A020Deferred renewal28136%30.6 (86th percentile)At or above the target on OPEX with old assets and a low capital cost for their age: a risk that renewals are deferred; check the renewal plan and quality.
A033Deferred renewal29237%30.7 (87th percentile)At or above the target on OPEX with old assets and a low capital cost for their age: a risk that renewals are deferred; check the renewal plan and quality.
A059Capitalisation53951%27.7 (73rd percentile)Efficient on OPEX, much lower on TOTEX, with a high capital cost share for its asset age: check the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary.
A063Offset by low CAPEX57837%44.0 (99th percentile)Below the target on OPEX, much higher on TOTEX with a low capital cost share: the OPEX gap is offset by low capital cost (repair instead of renewal, or costs expensed that others capitalise).
A067Deferred renewal26438%29.7 (83rd percentile)At or above the target on OPEX with old assets and a low capital cost for their age: a risk that renewals are deferred; check the renewal plan and quality.
A096Capitalisation158053%23.8 (43rd percentile)Efficient on OPEX, much lower on TOTEX, with a high capital cost share for its asset age: check the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary.

Investment that the saving pays back

An annual OPEX saving pays back a one-off investment of up to 7.02 times the saving over 10 years at 7% (annuity factor). For the secure basket that is up to 420.7m PLN (at least 87.9m PLN with 95% probability). Where the gap goes with old assets (A009, A081, A058, A014, A075), removing it may need renewal rather than management action alone: compare these amounts with the cost of the renewal programme.

UnitBasketSaving a yearBreak-even investmentAsset ageCAPEX a yearYears of CAPEX
A009Secure22.3m PLN156.9m PLN39.0 (98th percentile)56.7m PLN2.8
A081Large but uncertain19.9m PLN139.9m PLN29.1 (80th percentile)124.3m PLN1.1
A058Large but uncertain19.7m PLN138.1m PLN31.2 (90th percentile)138.3m PLN1.0
A083Secure15.7m PLN110.4m PLN27.5 (71st percentile)61.9m PLN1.8
A014Secure13.4m PLN94.1m PLN41.6 (99th percentile)65.9m PLN1.4
A075Conditional on quality8.1m PLN57.2m PLN37.6 (97th percentile)21.5m PLN2.7
A016Conditional on quality7.3m PLN51.0m PLN21.4 (30th percentile)38.3m PLN1.3
A074Large but uncertain6.2m PLN43.4m PLN27.0 (67th percentile)89.5m PLN0.5
A050Conditional on quality6.0m PLN42.4m PLN22.1 (32nd percentile)26.4m PLN1.6
A055Conditional on quality5.4m PLN37.9m PLN14.1 (7th percentile)137.0m PLN0.3

08Cost components

Where the excess sits: each unit's cost by component against the cost structure of the efficient units (median shares of the units at or above the target), taken at the unit's efficient cost. Components outside the unit's control are marked.

Excess by component, units below the target

Excess by component, units below the target050m100m150mOwn labour49.7m PLNContracted services82.8m PLNFault repair182.8m PLNVegetation management4.3m PLNShared servicesnot controllable4.3m PLNTaxes and feesnot controllable21.9m PLNBlue: components the units control; grey: components outside their control.
Data table
ComponentControllableShare in the efficient structureExcess, units below the targetExcess, all units
Own labour (own_labour)yes35.2%49.7m PLN78.8m PLN
Contracted services (contracted_services)yes21.4%82.8m PLN128.9m PLN
Fault repair (fault_repair)yes11.8%182.8m PLN207.7m PLN
Vegetation management (vegetation_management)yes7.1%4.3m PLN2.8m PLN
Shared services (shared_services)no14.7%4.3m PLN19.6m PLN
Taxes and fees (taxes_and_fees)no9.8%21.9m PLN32.1m PLN

Excess by component in the units with the largest saving

UnitExpected savingControllable excessExcess outside controlLargest components
A00922.3m PLN29.2m PLN-706k PLNfault repair +18.9m PLN, own labour +5.0m PLN
A08119.9m PLN34.3m PLN1.3m PLNfault repair +17.3m PLN, contracted services +12.4m PLN
A05819.7m PLN31.5m PLN3.2m PLNcontracted services +15.0m PLN, own labour +10.1m PLN
A08315.7m PLN23.8m PLN-971k PLNcontracted services +15.9m PLN, fault repair +15.3m PLN
A01413.4m PLN22.4m PLN-1.4m PLNfault repair +16.8m PLN, own labour +5.9m PLN
A0758.1m PLN11.8m PLN-1.3m PLNfault repair +10.9m PLN, vegetation management +992k PLN
A0167.3m PLN12.2m PLN-845k PLNfault repair +10.7m PLN, own labour +1.2m PLN
A0746.2m PLN1.1m PLN14.8m PLNtaxes and fees +14.9m PLN, contracted services +6.1m PLN

09What goes with higher cost

Operational metrics ranked by how strongly they go with estimated inefficiency (share of the explained part). These are associations, not causes; the levers are starting points for analysis.

What goes with higher costFailure or fault ratefailure_rate42%↑ higher values, higher inefficiencyAsset ageasset_age36%↑ higher values, higher inefficiencyCrew agecrew_age14%↓ lower values, higher inefficiencyOutsourcing shareoutsourcing_share6%↓ lower values, higher inefficiencyCapacity utilisationutilisation2%↑ higher values, higher inefficiencyOvertime shareovertime_share0%↓ lower values, higher inefficiency
Model quality: cross-validated R² 0.37 (reliable)
Data table
Metric%DirectionTypical levers
Failure or fault ratefailure_rate41.8%↑ higher values, higher inefficiencypredictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Asset ageasset_age35.7%↑ higher values, higher inefficiencya renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
Crew agecrew_age13.8%↓ lower values, higher inefficiency
Outsourcing shareoutsourcing_share6.0%↓ lower values, higher inefficiency
Capacity utilisationutilisation2.4%↑ higher values, higher inefficiency
Overtime shareovertime_share0.4%↓ lower values, higher inefficiency

Typical levers

10Peer groups

Units by peer group. The tick marks the group median; the benchmark of each group, suggested for comparing practices, is its most efficient unit whose quality (when measured) is not among the worst and that is not flagged in the TOTEX view.

How the groups were formed: Peer groups by customer density (customers per km² of service area), in quartiles from the densest: Urban, Suburban, Rural, Sparse.

Peer groups60%70%80%90%100%target 90%Urban (25)benchmark: A030 (97%)Suburban (25)benchmark: A069 (97%)Rural (24)benchmark: A019 (96%)Sparse (24)benchmark: A072 (95%)median
Data table
GroupUnitsMedian efficiencyExcess cost shareBenchmark
Urban2590.4%13.4%A030 (97%)
Suburban2590.6%10.3%A069 (97%)
Rural2490.9%13.0%A019 (96%)
Sparse2489.5%12.9%A072 (95%)

Benchmark profile by group

The benchmark of each group (its most efficient unit whose quality is not among the worst and that is not flagged in the TOTEX view) against the group median and the unit with the largest saving, on the same indicators.

Urban (25)

IndicatorBenchmark
A030
Group
median
Largest gap
A009
Cost efficiency97%90%67%
Cost per customers470 PLN439 PLN660 PLN
Cost per network length (km)9,655 PLN9,945 PLN15k PLN
Cost per stations17k PLN29k PLN56k PLN
Cost per energy delivered41k PLN54k PLN70k PLN
Failure or fault rate4.458.5412.8
Asset age13.925.739.0
Capacity utilisation0.3810.6700.645
Overtime share0.0580.0520.020
Outsourcing share0.3470.3690.337
Crew age45.244.947.7
SAIDI62.862.899.8
SAIFI1.121.362.03
Service area (km²)1,5171,3571,566
Forest cover0.2010.2000.294
Cable share0.4060.4130.353
CAPEX share48%44%40%

Suburban (25)

IndicatorBenchmark
A069
Group
median
Largest gap
A073
Cost efficiency97%91%79%
Cost per customers237 PLN434 PLN552 PLN
Cost per network length (km)9,989 PLN10k PLN15k PLN
Cost per stations30k PLN32k PLN32k PLN
Cost per energy delivered63k PLN60k PLN64k PLN
Failure or fault rate6.116.587.03
Asset age31.124.936.8
Capacity utilisation0.7740.6800.903
Overtime share0.0760.0750.077
Outsourcing share0.3170.3890.366
Crew age58.144.141.3
SAIDI62.687.264.7
SAIFI1.091.651.48
Service area (km²)1,8041,3731,277
Forest cover0.2090.2600.220
Cable share0.4520.3100.391
CAPEX share53%44%43%

Rural (24)

IndicatorBenchmark
A019
Group
median
Largest gap
A016
Cost efficiency96%91%77%
Cost per customers244 PLN446 PLN741 PLN
Cost per network length (km)12k PLN12k PLN13k PLN
Cost per stations38k PLN32k PLN44k PLN
Cost per energy delivered54k PLN60k PLN47k PLN
Failure or fault rate9.548.0818.6
Asset age16.124.421.4
Capacity utilisation0.4700.6860.577
Overtime share0.0240.0410.048
Outsourcing share0.3370.3490.319
Crew age47.444.047.3
SAIDI79.999.1131
SAIFI2.231.962.46
Service area (km²)1,6631,5082,394
Forest cover0.2840.2840.326
Cable share0.2550.3030.317
CAPEX share50%43%43%

Sparse (24)

IndicatorBenchmark
A072
Group
median
Largest gap
A075
Cost efficiency95%90%67%
Cost per customers370 PLN494 PLN1,420 PLN
Cost per network length (km)8,893 PLN12k PLN17k PLN
Cost per stations37k PLN34k PLN35k PLN
Cost per energy delivered50k PLN68k PLN86k PLN
Failure or fault rate7.567.7324.6
Asset age26.125.937.6
Capacity utilisation0.8890.7420.789
Overtime share0.0570.0490.084
Outsourcing share0.3430.3480.374
Crew age48.142.937.2
SAIDI120139318
SAIFI1.932.373.63
Service area (km²)1,9891,8662,456
Forest cover0.3440.3600.541
Cable share0.1980.1710.146
CAPEX share46%44%40%

11Units with the largest potential

The units with the largest saving at the target and what distinguishes them in the operational metrics.

A009Area 9 · UrbanSecure

Efficiency
67%[56%; 93%]
Saving at target
22.3m PLN[0 PLN; 32.7m PLN]
Rank
77 to 98 of 98
Benchmark
A030 (97%)Group Urban
A009 (Area 9)raises inefficiencylowers inefficiencyAsset age+6.6%Failure or fault rate+3.4%Crew age-0.9%Outsourcing share+0.2%approximate effect, % of the unit's cost

A081Area 81 · UrbanLarge but uncertain

Efficiency
81%[69%; 98%]
Saving at target
19.9m PLN[0 PLN; 44.0m PLN]
Rank
26 to 96 of 98
Benchmark
A030 (97%)Group Urban
A081 (Area 81)raises inefficiencylowers inefficiencyAsset age+2.1%Crew age+1.9%Failure or fault rate+1.0%Outsourcing share-0.2%approximate effect, % of the unit's cost

A058Area 58 · UrbanLarge but uncertain

Efficiency
81%[68%; 97%]
Saving at target
19.7m PLN[0 PLN; 42.8m PLN]
Rank
27 to 96 of 98
Benchmark
A030 (97%)Group Urban
A058 (Area 58)raises inefficiencylowers inefficiencyAsset age+3.0%Crew age+1.8%Failure or fault rate-1.3%Outsourcing share-0.1%approximate effect, % of the unit's cost

A083Area 83 · UrbanSecure

Efficiency
74%[63%; 96%]
Saving at target
15.7m PLN[0 PLN; 27.1m PLN]
Rank
53 to 98 of 98
Benchmark
A030 (97%)Group Urban
A083 (Area 83)raises inefficiencylowers inefficiencyFailure or fault rate+8.2%Asset age+1.3%Outsourcing share-1.2%Crew age+0.4%approximate effect, % of the unit's cost

A014Area 14 · UrbanSecure

Efficiency
78%[65%; 97%]
Saving at target
13.4m PLN[0 PLN; 26.2m PLN]
Rank
38 to 97 of 98
Benchmark
A030 (97%)Group Urban
A014 (Area 14)raises inefficiencylowers inefficiencyAsset age+7.8%Failure or fault rate+3.9%Outsourcing share+0.8%Crew age-0.6%approximate effect, % of the unit's cost

12Action plan

Recommendations by unit, data checks first. Each item gives the expected saving with its interval, the probability that the unit is below the target and the time horizon.

⚠ A017Area 17 · SparseHigh priority

Verify the cost record before acting
Cost far above what the frontier variables imply (robust z = 6.3) · scored against the frontier: efficiency 43% [33%; 82%] · immediate
Rationale

Scored against the frontier of the other units: efficiency 43% [33%; 82%]. Check for data errors, one-off items, allocation keys or a structural difference that the frontier variables miss; a residual rule cannot tell a very inefficient unit from an erroneous record.

⚠ A028Area 28 · RuralHigh priority

Verify the cost record before acting
Cost far above what the frontier variables imply (robust z = 8.9) · scored against the frontier: efficiency 34% [24%; 77%] · immediate
Rationale

Scored against the frontier of the other units: efficiency 34% [24%; 77%]. Check for data errors, one-off items, allocation keys or a structural difference that the frontier variables miss; a residual rule cannot tell a very inefficient unit from an erroneous record.

A009Area 9 · UrbanSecureHigh priority

Raise cost efficiency from 67% to 90%
Saving 22.3m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 32.7m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 97% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 156.9m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 39.0, 98th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 39.0 (98th percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Failure or fault rate: 12.8 (86th percentile) · benchmark A030: 4.45Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 97%; saving at the target 22,338,740 PLN (26.1% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 32,703,252]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.066 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.034 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A083Area 83 · UrbanSecureHigh priority

Raise cost efficiency from 74% to 90%
Saving 15.7m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 27.1m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 95% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 110.4m PLN over 10 years
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Failure or fault rate: 18.5 (97th percentile) · benchmark A030: 4.45Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
  • Asset age: 27.5 (71st percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 95%; saving at the target 15,717,906 PLN (17.7% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 27,119,119]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.082 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.013 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A014Area 14 · UrbanSecureHigh priority

Raise cost efficiency from 78% to 90%
Saving 13.4m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 26.2m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 93% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 94.1m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 41.6, 99th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 41.6 (99th percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Failure or fault rate: 13.5 (90th percentile) · benchmark A030: 4.45Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 93%; saving at the target 13,394,187 PLN (14.3% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 26,153,064]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.078 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.039 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A073Area 73 · SuburbanSecureHigh priority

Raise cost efficiency from 79% to 90%
Saving 5.0m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 9.9m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 91% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 35.3m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 36.8, 96th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 36.8 (96th percentile) · benchmark A069: 31.1Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 91%; saving at the target 5,023,171 PLN (12.6% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 9,879,620]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.056 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A093Area 93 · RuralSecureHigh priority

Raise cost efficiency from 78% to 90%
Saving 3.4m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 6.7m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 92% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 24.0m PLN over 10 years
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Failure or fault rate: 16.6 (94th percentile) · benchmark A019: 9.54Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 92%; saving at the target 3,423,446 PLN (13.6% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 6,696,838]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.066 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A081Area 81 · UrbanLarge but uncertainMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 81% to 90%
Saving 19.9m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 44.0m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 88% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 139.9m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 29.1, 80th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 29.1 (80th percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Crew age: 36.8 (4th percentile) · benchmark A030: 45.2counter-intuitive direction, see Limits of the method
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 88%; saving at the target 19,917,733 PLN (10.6% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 44,038,009]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.021 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Lower values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.019 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A058Area 58 · UrbanLarge but uncertainMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 81% to 90%
Saving 19.7m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 42.8m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 89% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Pays back an investment of up to 138.1m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 31.2, 90th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 31.2 (90th percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Crew age: 37.0 (5th percentile) · benchmark A030: 45.2counter-intuitive direction, see Limits of the method
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 89%; saving at the target 19,658,446 PLN (11.0% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 42,776,793]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.030 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Lower values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.018 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A075Area 75 · SparseConditional on qualityMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 67% to 90%
Saving 8.1m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 12.4m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 96% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Quality: SAIDI among the worst 20%; SAIFI among the worst 20%; plan cuts that keep quality within the requirements.
Pays back an investment of up to 57.2m PLN over 10 years (old assets: 37.6, 97th percentile)
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Failure or fault rate: 24.6 (99th percentile) · benchmark A072: 7.56Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
  • Asset age: 37.6 (97th percentile) · benchmark A072: 26.1Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Crew age: 37.2 (6th percentile) · benchmark A072: 48.1counter-intuitive direction, see Limits of the method
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 96%; saving at the target 8,149,798 PLN (25.5% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 12,374,127]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.135 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.060 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Lower values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.018 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A016Area 16 · RuralConditional on qualityMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 77% to 90%
Saving 7.3m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 13.6m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 92% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Quality: SAIDI among the worst 20%; SAIFI among the worst 20%; plan cuts that keep quality within the requirements.
Pays back an investment of up to 51.0m PLN over 10 years
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Failure or fault rate: 18.6 (98th percentile) · benchmark A019: 9.54Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 92%; saving at the target 7,265,360 PLN (14.5% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 13,598,548]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.083 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A074Area 74 · UrbanLarge but uncertainMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 86% to 90%
Saving 6.2m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 20.3m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 70% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Of this saving, 5.1m PLN sits in components outside the unit's control (taxes and fees); that part needs a decision above unit level.
Pays back an investment of up to 43.4m PLN over 10 years
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Asset age: 27.0 (67th percentile) · benchmark A030: 13.9Levers: a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep
  • Crew age: 40.0 (18th percentile) · benchmark A030: 45.2counter-intuitive direction, see Limits of the method
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 70%; saving at the target 6,185,545 PLN (5.3% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 20,281,503]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.011 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are a renewal plan prioritised by condition and cost of upkeep. An association, not a causal estimate.

Lower values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.011 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

A050Area 50 · RuralConditional on qualityMedium priority

Raise cost efficiency from 74% to 90%
Saving 6.0m PLN (95% interval 0 PLN to 10.3m PLN) · probability that the unit is below the target 95% · horizon 6 to 18 months
Quality: SAIFI among the worst 20%; plan cuts that keep quality within the requirements.
Pays back an investment of up to 42.4m PLN over 10 years
What to look athorizon 3 to 12 months
  • Failure or fault rate: 16.8 (95th percentile) · benchmark A019: 9.54Levers: predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most
Benchmarkhorizon 3 to 6 months

A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural: compare practices

Rationale

Probability of being below the target: 95%; saving at the target 6,033,911 PLN (17.7% of the unit's cost), 95% interval [0; 10,273,272]. Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5).

Higher values go with higher estimated inefficiency in this panel; attribution to this unit +0.068 (second-stage model, cross-validated R² 0.37). If it is confirmed, the usual levers are predictive maintenance and targeted renewal of the assets that fail most. An association, not a causal estimate.

Most efficient unit of the same group by posterior mean among the units whose quality is not among the worst and that are not flagged in the TOTEX view; rank intervals of a single cross-section are wide, so the peer is a starting point for comparison, not a proven best practice.

The full list (153 recommendations) is in the appendix and in the Excel report.

13Data quality

Units whose cost is far from what their frontier variables imply are set aside: they do not shape the frontier, they are scored against it and left out of the totals. A residual rule cannot tell a very inefficient unit from an erroneous record, so these come first.

Data qualityscreening threshold ±3.5-4-202468⚠ A017⚠ A028
Axis: robust z of the cost residual (0 = cost in line with the frontier variables).
UnitNameGroupzEfficiency
A017Area 17Sparse6.343% [33%; 82%]
A028Area 28Rural8.934% [24%; 77%]

14Limits of the method

What this analysis cannot tell, and what would close the gap.

15Method and assumptions

Model: a Bayesian stochastic cost frontier. The logarithm of cost is the sum of the efficient cost for the unit's frontier variables, symmetric noise and a one-sided inefficiency term (half-normal law). Efficiency is the ratio of efficient to observed cost.

Frontier variables (things the unit cannot choose): customers, network length (km) [network_km], stations, energy delivered [energy_delivered] (scale); service area (km²) [service_area_km2], forest cover [forest_share], cable share [cable_share] (condition). Operational metrics (second stage): failure or fault rate [failure_rate], asset age [asset_age], capacity utilisation [utilisation], overtime share [overtime_share], outsourcing share [outsourcing_share], crew age [crew_age].

Before the report gives any figure, three safeguards run: residual screening without a quota, a check for curvature of the cost function and an evidence gate (skewness test of the cost residuals).

Assumptions: half-normal law, prior median efficiency r* = 0.85, screening: residual rule (3.5). Intervals are 95% equal-tailed posterior intervals.

Estimation: marginal sampler, 4 chains with 2000 kept draws each; convergence: maximum R-hat 1.004, minimum effective sample size 1,355 (OK).

Decision layer: the expected saving is the posterior mean of the saving at the target and the defensible amount its 5% quantile, both from the joint posterior draws of all units. A unit goes to the secure basket when the probability of being below the target is at least 90%; to the large but uncertain basket when its expected saving reaches 1% of the portfolio and the probability is at least 50%; to the basket conditional on quality when a quality indicator is among the worst 20% or beyond its limit. Break-even investment: the annual saving times the annuity factor 7.02 (10 years at 7%).

TOTEX: the same frontier (units, variables, size term) fitted to OPEX + CAPEX; the flags compare the two rankings and the capital cost share against asset age.

Reliability notes

Cost elasticities

VariableRoleElasticity95% interval
customersscale0.309[0.216; 0.397]
network length (km) [network_km]scale0.180[0.103; 0.255]
stationsscale0.373[0.287; 0.463]
energy delivered [energy_delivered]scale0.128[0.034; 0.219]
service area (km²) [service_area_km2]condition0.143[0.071; 0.216]
forest cover [forest_share]condition0.084[0.016; 0.159]
cable share [cable_share]condition-0.002[-0.087; 0.088]

Elasticity of cost with respect to scale: 0.990 (95% interval 0.940 to 1.041).

16Appendix: all units

Click a column header to sort.

UnitNameGroupCostEfficiency95% intervalRankExcess costSaving at targetStatus
A001Area 1Sparse8.0m PLN84.1%[72%; 98%]16 to 941.3m PLN595k PLNbelow target
A002Area 2Sparse13.7m PLN80.5%[68%; 98%]28 to 962.7m PLN1.5m PLNbelow target
A003Area 3Sparse9.3m PLN84.3%[73%; 98%]18 to 941.5m PLN676k PLNbelow target
A004Area 4Sparse17.7m PLN94.6%[86%; 100%]2 to 73963k PLN71k PLN
A005Area 5Sparse3.9m PLN89.1%[75%; 99%]5 to 91424k PLN134k PLNbelow target
A006Area 6Suburban22.1m PLN90.6%[79%; 99%]5 to 852.1m PLN479k PLN
A007Area 7Sparse9.3m PLN95.3%[86%; 100%]1 to 72442k PLN27k PLN
A008Area 8Urban51.3m PLN94.8%[85%; 100%]2 to 742.7m PLN201k PLN
A009Area 9Urban85.7m PLN66.7%[56%; 93%]77 to 9828.5m PLN22.3m PLNSecure
A010Area 10Urban61.8m PLN91.9%[81%; 100%]3 to 835.0m PLN906k PLN
A011Area 11Rural41.9m PLN94.4%[85%; 100%]2 to 752.3m PLN220k PLN
A012Area 12Suburban22.9m PLN89.4%[78%; 99%]6 to 872.4m PLN666k PLNbelow target
A013Area 13Suburban58.6m PLN91.9%[81%; 100%]3 to 834.7m PLN836k PLN
A014Area 14Urban93.8m PLN77.5%[65%; 97%]38 to 9721.1m PLN13.4m PLNSecure
A015Area 15Suburban14.3m PLN90.7%[80%; 99%]5 to 851.3m PLN302k PLN
A016Area 16Rural50.0m PLN77.3%[65%; 97%]39 to 9711.4m PLN7.3m PLNConditional on quality
A017Area 17Sparse68.6m PLN43.5%[33%; 82%]set aside
A018Area 18Urban79.7m PLN90.4%[79%; 99%]5 to 867.7m PLN1.8m PLN
A019Area 19Rural11.9m PLN95.8%[87%; 100%]1 to 70498k PLN24k PLN
A020Area 20Rural15.8m PLN93.4%[83%; 100%]2 to 791.1m PLN128k PLN
A021Area 21Urban32.3m PLN86.5%[75%; 99%]10 to 914.4m PLN1.7m PLNbelow target
A022Area 22Suburban40.4m PLN83.0%[72%; 98%]21 to 956.9m PLN3.4m PLNConditional on quality
A023Area 23Sparse10.1m PLN90.3%[78%; 100%]4 to 88981k PLN256k PLN
A024Area 24Rural34.0m PLN94.8%[86%; 100%]2 to 731.8m PLN130k PLN
A025Area 25Suburban25.6m PLN91.7%[81%; 100%]4 to 822.1m PLN379k PLN
A026Area 26Suburban19.1m PLN87.4%[76%; 99%]10 to 902.4m PLN849k PLNbelow target
A027Area 27Rural24.4m PLN93.4%[84%; 100%]2 to 771.6m PLN181k PLN
A028Area 28Rural122.3m PLN33.6%[24%; 77%]set aside
A029Area 29Sparse8.0m PLN89.6%[77%; 99%]6 to 87833k PLN236k PLNbelow target
A030Area 30Urban68.9m PLN97.4%[91%; 100%]1 to 571.8m PLN22k PLN
A031Area 31Rural16.8m PLN89.8%[79%; 99%]6 to 861.7m PLN431k PLNbelow target
A032Area 32Sparse4.6m PLN85.7%[73%; 99%]13 to 93655k PLN273k PLNbelow target
A033Area 33Rural21.6m PLN93.2%[83%; 100%]2 to 781.5m PLN181k PLN
A034Area 34Suburban80.2m PLN91.1%[80%; 100%]3 to 857.1m PLN1.5m PLN
A035Area 35Sparse19.9m PLN91.7%[81%; 100%]3 to 831.7m PLN316k PLN
A036Area 36Urban102.3m PLN93.4%[83%; 100%]2 to 786.7m PLN815k PLN
A037Area 37Urban82.8m PLN90.5%[79%; 99%]4 to 867.9m PLN1.8m PLN
A038Area 38Sparse18.8m PLN89.5%[78%; 99%]5 to 862.0m PLN529k PLNbelow target
A039Area 39Sparse5.8m PLN86.4%[75%; 99%]11 to 92791k PLN311k PLNbelow target
A040Area 40Sparse11.5m PLN85.5%[74%; 98%]15 to 921.7m PLN704k PLNbelow target
A041Area 41Urban43.5m PLN93.8%[84%; 100%]2 to 782.7m PLN280k PLN
A042Area 42Sparse16.0m PLN95.2%[86%; 100%]2 to 71775k PLN47k PLN
A043Area 43Sparse9.1m PLN93.6%[84%; 100%]2 to 77584k PLN65k PLN
A044Area 44Sparse7.6m PLN96.7%[89%; 100%]1 to 63249k PLN5,538 PLN
A045Area 45Rural30.0m PLN92.7%[82%; 100%]2 to 802.2m PLN322k PLN
A046Area 46Sparse30.3m PLN92.9%[82%; 100%]2 to 792.1m PLN308k PLN
A047Area 47Sparse61.5m PLN83.1%[71%; 98%]16 to 9510.4m PLN5.3m PLNConditional on quality
A048Area 48Suburban53.7m PLN92.0%[79%; 100%]2 to 854.3m PLN918k PLN
A049Area 49Suburban9.9m PLN95.4%[86%; 100%]1 to 70458k PLN29k PLN
A050Area 50Rural34.2m PLN74.4%[63%; 95%]53 to 988.8m PLN6.0m PLNConditional on quality
A051Area 51Sparse13.3m PLN87.3%[76%; 99%]10 to 901.7m PLN594k PLNbelow target
A052Area 52Rural36.3m PLN79.3%[67%; 97%]32 to 967.5m PLN4.5m PLNConditional on quality
A053Area 53Rural13.0m PLN93.4%[83%; 100%]2 to 80854k PLN102k PLN
A054Area 54Rural9.5m PLN92.1%[81%; 100%]3 to 82752k PLN130k PLN
A055Area 55Urban153.8m PLN88.7%[77%; 99%]7 to 8817.4m PLN5.4m PLNConditional on quality
A056Area 56Urban26.7m PLN94.1%[84%; 100%]2 to 771.6m PLN154k PLN
A057Area 57Suburban39.2m PLN92.8%[82%; 100%]3 to 792.8m PLN396k PLN
A058Area 58Urban178.9m PLN80.6%[68%; 97%]27 to 9634.7m PLN19.7m PLNLarge but uncertain
A059Area 59Suburban32.1m PLN95.7%[87%; 100%]1 to 691.4m PLN68k PLN
A060Area 60Suburban28.5m PLN90.6%[80%; 99%]5 to 852.7m PLN609k PLN
A061Area 61Suburban31.8m PLN91.7%[81%; 100%]3 to 832.6m PLN480k PLN
A062Area 62Rural20.4m PLN76.1%[65%; 96%]47 to 974.9m PLN3.2m PLNConditional on quality
A063Area 63Urban59.6m PLN89.6%[79%; 99%]6 to 866.2m PLN1.6m PLNbelow target
A064Area 64Suburban28.0m PLN87.7%[76%; 99%]8 to 893.4m PLN1.2m PLNbelow target
A065Area 65Urban78.2m PLN92.6%[82%; 100%]3 to 815.8m PLN887k PLN
A066Area 66Rural25.6m PLN81.3%[70%; 98%]27 to 954.8m PLN2.6m PLNConditional on quality
A067Area 67Urban17.7m PLN93.4%[83%; 100%]2 to 781.2m PLN141k PLN
A068Area 68Rural19.3m PLN83.6%[72%; 98%]18 to 943.2m PLN1.5m PLNbelow target
A069Area 69Suburban30.3m PLN97.1%[90%; 100%]1 to 58875k PLN15k PLN
A070Area 70Suburban42.1m PLN82.7%[72%; 98%]23 to 947.3m PLN3.7m PLNLarge but uncertain
A071Area 71Urban70.1m PLN89.7%[79%; 99%]5 to 877.2m PLN1.9m PLNbelow target
A072Area 72Sparse15.9m PLN95.3%[87%; 100%]1 to 71747k PLN42k PLN
A073Area 73Suburban39.8m PLN79.1%[68%; 97%]34 to 968.3m PLN5.0m PLNSecure
A074Area 74Urban117.8m PLN86.5%[75%; 99%]11 to 9215.9m PLN6.2m PLNLarge but uncertain
A075Area 75Sparse32.0m PLN67.3%[55%; 93%]71 to 9810.5m PLN8.1m PLNConditional on quality
A076Area 76Suburban41.8m PLN90.4%[79%; 99%]4 to 864.0m PLN972k PLN
A077Area 77Urban87.0m PLN94.2%[85%; 100%]2 to 755.1m PLN452k PLN
A078Area 78Suburban38.9m PLN93.9%[84%; 100%]2 to 762.4m PLN245k PLN
A079Area 79Rural18.6m PLN89.8%[79%; 99%]6 to 861.9m PLN484k PLNbelow target
A080Area 80Sparse6.9m PLN90.6%[79%; 99%]4 to 85651k PLN152k PLN
A081Area 81Urban187.0m PLN80.9%[69%; 98%]26 to 9635.6m PLN19.9m PLNLarge but uncertain
A082Area 82Suburban33.1m PLN90.3%[79%; 99%]5 to 873.2m PLN782k PLN
A083Area 83Urban89.0m PLN74.4%[63%; 96%]53 to 9822.8m PLN15.7m PLNSecure
A084Area 84Sparse27.4m PLN91.5%[80%; 100%]3 to 822.3m PLN458k PLN
A085Area 85Urban88.2m PLN87.3%[74%; 99%]8 to 9211.2m PLN4.2m PLNLarge but uncertain
A086Area 86Suburban37.5m PLN91.8%[81%; 100%]3 to 823.1m PLN535k PLN
A087Area 87Suburban28.2m PLN87.6%[77%; 99%]9 to 903.5m PLN1.2m PLNbelow target
A088Area 88Sparse20.8m PLN83.9%[73%; 98%]17 to 933.3m PLN1.6m PLNbelow target
A089Area 89Suburban37.2m PLN83.5%[72%; 98%]20 to 946.1m PLN3.0m PLNLarge but uncertain
A090Area 90Rural18.9m PLN94.5%[85%; 100%]2 to 731.0m PLN83k PLN
A091Area 91Rural32.2m PLN85.2%[73%; 99%]13 to 934.8m PLN2.1m PLNLarge but uncertain
A092Area 92Rural7.5m PLN87.6%[75%; 99%]8 to 91935k PLN328k PLNbelow target
A093Area 93Rural25.2m PLN78.2%[66%; 97%]35 to 975.5m PLN3.4m PLNSecure
A094Area 94Urban31.4m PLN87.5%[75%; 99%]9 to 913.9m PLN1.4m PLNbelow target
A095Area 95Rural9.4m PLN89.8%[79%; 99%]5 to 87966k PLN250k PLNbelow target
A096Area 96Urban25.1m PLN94.4%[85%; 100%]2 to 751.4m PLN124k PLN
A097Area 97Urban39.3m PLN93.7%[83%; 100%]2 to 782.5m PLN282k PLN
A098Area 98Rural18.2m PLN94.1%[84%; 100%]2 to 761.1m PLN104k PLN
A099Area 99Rural16.0m PLN94.0%[84%; 100%]2 to 75955k PLN92k PLN
A100Area 100Suburban17.1m PLN85.3%[74%; 98%]16 to 922.5m PLN1.1m PLNbelow target
All recommendations (153)
UnitPriorityTypeActionSavingHorizon
A017High priorityData checkVerify the cost record before acting: unit set aside by the screening rule (cost far above what its frontier variables imply, robust z = +6.3)immediate
A028High priorityData checkVerify the cost record before acting: unit set aside by the screening rule (cost far above what its frontier variables imply, robust z = +8.9)immediate
A009High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 67% to the target of 90%22.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A009Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 38.969, 98th percentile)3 to 12 months
A009Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.833, 86th percentile)3 to 12 months
A009Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A083High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 74% to the target of 90%15.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A083Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 18.454, 97th percentile)3 to 12 months
A083Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 27.486, 71st percentile)3 to 12 months
A083Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A014High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 78% to the target of 90%13.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A014Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 41.648, 99th percentile)3 to 12 months
A014Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 13.470, 90th percentile)3 to 12 months
A014Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A073High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 79% to the target of 90%5.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A073Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 36.764, 96th percentile)3 to 12 months
A073Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A093High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 78% to the target of 90%3.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A093Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.570, 94th percentile)3 to 12 months
A093Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A081Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%19.9m PLN6 to 18 months
A081Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 29.119, 80th percentile)3 to 12 months
A081Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 36.811, 4th percentile)3 to 12 months
A081Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A058Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%19.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A058Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 31.172, 90th percentile)3 to 12 months
A058Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 37.023, 5th percentile)3 to 12 months
A058Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A075Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 67% to the target of 90%8.1m PLN6 to 18 months
A075Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 24.587, 99th percentile)3 to 12 months
A075Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 37.597, 97th percentile)3 to 12 months
A075Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 37.204, 6th percentile)3 to 12 months
A075Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A016Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 77% to the target of 90%7.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A016Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 18.564, 98th percentile)3 to 12 months
A016Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A074Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 86% to the target of 90%6.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A074Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 27.023, 67th percentile)3 to 12 months
A074Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 40.048, 18th percentile)3 to 12 months
A074Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A050Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 74% to the target of 90%6.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A050Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.779, 95th percentile)3 to 12 months
A050Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A055Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 89% to the target of 90%5.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A055Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.088, 92nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A055Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A047Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%5.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A047Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 14.003, 91st percentile)3 to 12 months
A047Medium priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 33.144, 2nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A047Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A052Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 79% to the target of 90%4.5m PLN6 to 18 months
A052Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.792, 85th percentile)3 to 12 months
A052Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 29.587, 82nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A052Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A085Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 87% to the target of 90%4.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A085Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A070Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%3.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A070Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 11.920, 81st percentile)3 to 12 months
A070Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 40.104, 19th percentile)3 to 12 months
A070Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A022Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%3.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A022Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 17.358, 96th percentile)3 to 12 months
A022Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A062Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 76% to the target of 90%3.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A062Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.516, 84th percentile)3 to 12 months
A062Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 39.018, 12th percentile)3 to 12 months
A062Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A089Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%3.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A089Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.471, 83rd percentile)3 to 12 months
A089Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A066Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%2.6m PLN6 to 18 months
A066Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 36.098, 95th percentile)3 to 12 months
A066Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 39.586, 17th percentile)3 to 12 months
A066Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A091Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 85% to the target of 90%2.1m PLN6 to 18 months
A091Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 32.871, 92nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A091Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 11.361, 80th percentile)3 to 12 months
A091Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 39.072, 13th percentile)3 to 12 months
A091Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A071Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%1.9m PLN6 to 18 months
A071Low priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 11.164, 78th percentile)3 to 12 months
A071Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A021Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 86% to the target of 90%1.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A021Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 27.421, 70th percentile)3 to 12 months
A021Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A063Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%1.6m PLN6 to 18 months
A063Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 43.951, 99th percentile)3 to 12 months
A063Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck whether low capital cost offsets the OPEX gap: rank 57 of 98 on OPEX, 8 on TOTEX, capital cost share 37%3 to 6 months
A063Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A088Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%1.6m PLN6 to 18 months
A088Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 39.090, 14th percentile)3 to 12 months
A088Low priorityDriverExamine 'outsourcing_share' (value 0.210, 1st percentile)3 to 12 months
A088Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A002Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 80% to the target of 90%1.5m PLN6 to 18 months
A002Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 29.132, 81st percentile)3 to 12 months
A002Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 40.302, 20th percentile)3 to 12 months
A002Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A068Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%1.5m PLN6 to 18 months
A068Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 26.884, 66th percentile)3 to 12 months
A068Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A094Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 87% to the target of 90%1.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A094Low priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 10.414, 73rd percentile)3 to 12 months
A094Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A030 (efficiency 97%) in group Urban3 to 6 months
A087Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 88% to the target of 90%1.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A087Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A064Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 88% to the target of 90%1.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A064Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A100Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 85% to the target of 90%1.1m PLN6 to 18 months
A100Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 30.438, 85th percentile)3 to 12 months
A100Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A026Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 87% to the target of 90%849k PLN6 to 18 months
A026Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A040Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 85% to the target of 90%704k PLN6 to 18 months
A040Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A003Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%676k PLN6 to 18 months
A003Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 38.230, 9th percentile)3 to 12 months
A003Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A012Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 89% to the target of 90%666k PLN6 to 18 months
A012Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A069 (efficiency 97%) in group Suburban3 to 6 months
A001Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%595k PLN6 to 18 months
A001Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 27.252, 69th percentile)3 to 12 months
A001Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A051Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 87% to the target of 90%594k PLN6 to 18 months
A051Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A038Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%529k PLN6 to 18 months
A038Low priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 33.062, 1st percentile)3 to 12 months
A038Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A079Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%484k PLN6 to 18 months
A079Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 28.850, 78th percentile)3 to 12 months
A079Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A031Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%431k PLN6 to 18 months
A031Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A092Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 88% to the target of 90%328k PLN6 to 18 months
A092Low priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 13.028, 88th percentile)3 to 12 months
A092Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 27.076, 68th percentile)3 to 12 months
A092Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A039Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 86% to the target of 90%311k PLN6 to 18 months
A039Low priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 13.393, 89th percentile)3 to 12 months
A039Low priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 28.590, 77th percentile)3 to 12 months
A039Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A032Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 86% to the target of 90%273k PLN6 to 18 months
A032Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A095Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%250k PLN6 to 18 months
A095Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A019 (efficiency 96%) in group Rural3 to 6 months
A029Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 90% to the target of 90%236k PLN6 to 18 months
A029Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A005Low priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 89% to the target of 90%134k PLN6 to 18 months
A005Low priorityBenchmarkCompare practices with peer A072 (efficiency 95%) in group Sparse3 to 6 months
A020Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 36%)3 to 6 months
A033Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 37%)3 to 6 months
A059Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary: rank 5 of 98 on OPEX, 39 on TOTEX, capital cost share 51%3 to 6 months
A067Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 38%)3 to 6 months
A096Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary: rank 15 of 98 on OPEX, 80 on TOTEX, capital cost share 53%3 to 6 months

All recommendations (153)

Printed: data checks and high- and medium-priority items (54 of 153); the full list is in the interactive report and in the Excel workbook.

UnitPriorityTypeActionSavingHorizon
A017High priorityData checkVerify the cost record before acting: unit set aside by the screening rule (cost far above what its frontier variables imply, robust z = +6.3)immediate
A028High priorityData checkVerify the cost record before acting: unit set aside by the screening rule (cost far above what its frontier variables imply, robust z = +8.9)immediate
A009High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 67% to the target of 90%22.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A009Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 38.969, 98th percentile)3 to 12 months
A009Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.833, 86th percentile)3 to 12 months
A083High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 74% to the target of 90%15.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A083Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 18.454, 97th percentile)3 to 12 months
A014High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 78% to the target of 90%13.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A014Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 41.648, 99th percentile)3 to 12 months
A014Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 13.470, 90th percentile)3 to 12 months
A073High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 79% to the target of 90%5.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A073Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 36.764, 96th percentile)3 to 12 months
A093High priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 78% to the target of 90%3.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A093Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.570, 94th percentile)3 to 12 months
A081Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%19.9m PLN6 to 18 months
A081Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 29.119, 80th percentile)3 to 12 months
A058Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%19.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A058Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 31.172, 90th percentile)3 to 12 months
A075Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 67% to the target of 90%8.1m PLN6 to 18 months
A075Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 24.587, 99th percentile)3 to 12 months
A075Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 37.597, 97th percentile)3 to 12 months
A016Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 77% to the target of 90%7.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A016Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 18.564, 98th percentile)3 to 12 months
A074Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 86% to the target of 90%6.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A050Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 74% to the target of 90%6.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A050Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.779, 95th percentile)3 to 12 months
A055Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 89% to the target of 90%5.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A055Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 16.088, 92nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A047Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%5.3m PLN6 to 18 months
A047Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 14.003, 91st percentile)3 to 12 months
A047Medium priorityDriverExamine 'crew_age' (value 33.144, 2nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A052Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 79% to the target of 90%4.5m PLN6 to 18 months
A052Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.792, 85th percentile)3 to 12 months
A052Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 29.587, 82nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A085Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 87% to the target of 90%4.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A070Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%3.7m PLN6 to 18 months
A070Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 11.920, 81st percentile)3 to 12 months
A022Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 83% to the target of 90%3.4m PLN6 to 18 months
A022Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 17.358, 96th percentile)3 to 12 months
A062Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 76% to the target of 90%3.2m PLN6 to 18 months
A062Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.516, 84th percentile)3 to 12 months
A089Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 84% to the target of 90%3.0m PLN6 to 18 months
A089Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 12.471, 83rd percentile)3 to 12 months
A066Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 81% to the target of 90%2.6m PLN6 to 18 months
A066Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 36.098, 95th percentile)3 to 12 months
A091Medium priorityEfficiency gapClose the efficiency gap: lift cost efficiency from 85% to the target of 90%2.1m PLN6 to 18 months
A091Medium priorityDriverExamine the asset age ('asset_age' = 32.871, 92nd percentile)3 to 12 months
A091Medium priorityDriverExamine the failure or fault rate ('failure_rate' = 11.361, 80th percentile)3 to 12 months
A063Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck whether low capital cost offsets the OPEX gap: rank 57 of 98 on OPEX, 8 on TOTEX, capital cost share 37%3 to 6 months
A020Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 36%)3 to 6 months
A033Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 37%)3 to 6 months
A059Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary: rank 5 of 98 on OPEX, 39 on TOTEX, capital cost share 51%3 to 6 months
A067Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the renewal plan and quality: at or above the target on OPEX, with old assets and a low capital cost for their age (capital cost share 38%)3 to 6 months
A096Medium priorityTOTEX checkCheck the capitalisation rules and the OPEX/CAPEX boundary: rank 15 of 98 on OPEX, 80 on TOTEX, capital cost share 53%3 to 6 months